[ BDSN ] Why 84% of social media brand videos fail

🕹️ 84% of TIKTOK BRAND VIDEOS FAIL - HERE’S WHAT TO DO

TikTok, or something like it if it is banned, is the future of social commerce. But if you’re an Amazon seller hoping to expand, here’s a sobering stat:

👉 84% of branded TikTok videos flop.

They fail to grab attention. They don’t generate positive emotion. And worse—24% actually spark negative reactions like fear, shame, or disgust.

According to DAIVID's recent study on creative effectiveness:

• Only 16% of brand videos scored above average on attention and emotional impact.

• 60% were forgettable.

• A full quarter triggered damaging emotional responses.

💥 3 Big Reasons TikTok Brand Videos Bomb:

1. Overproduction kills authenticity. TikTok isn’t Netflix, it’s the lunchroom, not the boardroom.

2. They focus on selling, not story. Emotional engagement wins: hope, humor, trust, admiration.

3. Brands don’t test enough creators. Volume beats precision, especially early on.

🎎 Meanwhile in China: Leadership Overhaul and Power Moves

TikTok’s parent company ByteDance sent a clear signal last month:
“If US sellers won’t crack the code, we’ll import what worked in China.”

Executives from Douyin (China’s TikTok equivalent) replaced dozens of Seattle-based staff, changed internal language from English to Mandarin, and started remaking TikTok Shop in the image of Douyin’s $490B commerce juggernaut.

Why? Because TikTok Shop missed its $17.5B sales goal by almost half last year in the US.

And while internal chaos led to mass resignations and layoffs, the new regime is laser-focused on turning TikTok into Amazon’s top e-com rival—especially as Trump grants yet another 90-day extension to avoid a full ban.

🚀 Obvi’s Smart 9-Figure TikTok Flywheel

9-figure brand Obvi has built a performance UGC machine on TikTok Shop. It’s not just about creators—it’s about systems.

Here’s how they do it:

🌀 Obvi’s 7-Step UGC Flywheel:

1. Cast a Wide Net (Volume > Precision)

They use:

• TikTok Shop Affiliate Center (plus bots)

• AI creator platforms like Insense

• Discord groups + inbound applications
  ➡️ Goal: Create a constant flood of fresh content.

2. Be Generous with Commissions

• 25–30% base commission

• +10% GMV Max Ad revenue share
  ➡️ You want creators hustling for you.

3. Keep Testing Simple

• Send product → Give brief → Post → Boost with Spark Ads

• Short briefs with problem, what NOT to say, and 2–3 example videos
  ➡️ Simplicity = speed and authenticity.

4. Filter for Performance

• Only creators with consistent posts and sales stay in
  ➡️ No GMV = no second chance.

5. Build a Creator Community

• Discord channels for winning videos, tips, Spark codes
  ➡️ Let them learn and compete with each other.

6. Run Monthly Incentive Campaigns

• $2K GMV = iPhone

• $10K GMV = vacation
  ➡️ Friendly competition turns creators into your growth engine.

7. GMV Max Everything

• Boost every winning video via GMV Max
  ➡️ Paid ads amplify organic momentum and give you data.

Result? Obvi turns chaos into repeatable, scalable content—and not just for TikTok. Their best-performing videos get recycled across Meta and beyond.

You can also now use Amazon’s new Creator Connections to connect with creators on Amazon too, as Jordi Ordonez recently mentioned in his newsletter.

💡 FastMoss is Showing You the Money

FastMoss just dropped the CAP (Creator Agency Partner) Rankings—think of it like the Billboard Top 100, but for TikTok money-makers.

You can now track:

• Which agencies manage the most creators

• What revenue those creators are driving

• Which categories (beauty, wellness, gadgets, etc.) are exploding

It’s your hit list. Partner with the agencies moving real product. Skip the talkers.

📦 The Bottom Line for Amazon Sellers

• TikTok’s chaos = your opportunity—if you play it like a system, not a gamble.

• The UGC flywheel lets you test hundreds of creator-led messages—without burning your ad budget.

• Volume, emotion, simplicity, and community > polish, overproduction, and control.

Social commerce is the future and even more important now in an AI world. TikTok is a major player in the future of ecom traffic—and the smartest sellers are already cashing in.

💸 AMAZON’S “PROACTIVE REIMBURSEMENT” COSTING YOU $

Amazon promotes its Proactive Reimbursement program as a time-saving solution for FBA sellers. It sounds great—automatic claims, no need to file.

But here’s what Amazon doesn’t tell you:

Amazon’s proactive investigation is not a claim - lost Inbound units are NOT proactively reimbursed!

The bulk of the proactive reimbursements only cover warehouse lost and damaged units
And if you don’t file within 60 days, you lose your reimbursement eligibility.

🚨 The Hidden Risk Behind Amazon’s “Helpfulness”

When warehouse inventory goes missing or is damaged, Amazon may flag it and open an internal investigation. But unless you file an official claim within 60 days, Amazon can quietly stop investigating and mark the units as ineligible

Annoyingly, sellers who file early (within 30 days) often receive this response:

“Please wait 30 days before filing.”

But if you don’t refile before day 60, Amazon declines the claim for being outside the reimbursement window.

And in some cases, even if you file between 30-60 days, Amazon can tell you:

“This has been flagged for proactive reimbursement.” and close the case … 

… then later, mark the units as ineligible for missing the claim window.

Amazon’s Tactic: Delay, Dismiss, Expire

Amazon uses terms like “automated” and “proactive” to build trust—but in practice, they may avoid completing investigations and let your eligibility lapse. Not to mention, lost inbound units are not included.

Your Reimbursement Timeline for Warehouse Lost and Damaged Units:

• Day 0–30
   Avoid filing early — Amazon may auto-reject your claim.
  

• Day 31–59
   This is your window. File to preserve eligibility.

Even after filing, Amazon may prematurely close your case. If that happens, you must reply within 5 days—or risk the claim expiring. 

Handling claims manually is time-consuming and error-prone. That’s why a lot of sellers (including brand like Natural Dog, True Classic and Crossnet) trust top reimbursement experts like TrueOps to help protect their profits.

🛍️ AI AGENTS: NEXT THREAT to AMAZON & WALMART

AI shopping agents like ChatGPT, OpenAI’s Operator, and Perplexity are becoming powerful tools that:

• Understand natural queries (“Plan a unicorn-themed birthday party”).

• Automatically compare products, pricing, and availability.

• Complete transactions through APIs or partner networks.

Retailers are racing to adapt: Walmart is building its own shopping bots inside its app while preparing for third-party agents. Amazon’s heavy reliance on advertising revenue and marketplace interface may be undermined as these AI agents sidestep traditional browsing.

Amazon’s vulnerability:

• Advertising and marketplace visibility could drop if users bypass Amazon’s UI.

• AI agents might negotiate directly with sellers, impacting Amazon's pricing and take rate.
  

• Walmart’s opportunity:

  • With less dependency on ad revenue and a blend of physical+online channels, Walmart sees AI as a chance to deepen loyalty and streamline operations.

  • CTO Hari Vasudev emphasizes evolving ad strategies and preparing for agent‑to‑agent protocols.

What Sellers Should Do Now

• Make product data AI-friendly: Enrich listings with structured data, full attributes, and clear semantics with tools like ReFiBuy are emerging to assist

• Optimize for AI discovery, not just traditional SEO, think question‑answer format and conversational copy.

• Monitor AI visibility on ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Operator. Adapt pricing dynamically as AI bots will check all options instantly.

• Diversify your channels: Focus on brand-owned traffic like email, SMS, or direct‑to‑consumer to reduce reliance on marketplace exposure.

AI shopping agents are turning into the new storefronts, sometimes bypassing Amazon and Walmart altogether. For brands, AI optimization isn’t optional, it’s essential. Boost your product intelligence now or risk getting relegated to the back of the digital shelf.

Want to scale up your new product launches into listings that make $100K+ yearly revenue in less than 2 months?

Sending free products to Micro-Influencers using the platform Stack Influence which automates influencer collaborations at scale (get thousands of collabs per month) will help increase your new product Amazon ranking, generate UGC, and boost up your recurring revenue like never before.

Top Amazon brands like Thrasio, Unilever, and Magic Spoon have turned their new Amazon product launches into listings with monthly revenue on pace to break $100K over the year,

 Here are the top reasons why brands love to work with Stack Influence:

• 📈Increase Amazon listing search positioning (drive high volume external traffic sales) 

• 🤑Pay influencers only in products (stop negotiating fees with every influencer)

• 📸Generate branded image/video UGC with full legal rights (no timeframe or usage restrictions)

• 🤝Develop affiliate relationships (easily identify top influencer candidates to work with in the long run)

• 🤖Automate influencer collaborations from A-Z (save over 175 management hours per month)
  
  Don't believe it?
  Check out the results from this Micro Influencer campaign which went from 0 to 447 avg monthly recurring sales and is on pace to break $150K in yearly revenue on Amazon.
  
  Take your new product launches to the next level by increasing your Amazon listings organic search positioning sending free products to Micro-Influencers in 2025.
  
  Get 10% OFF by signing up this month

😱 AMAZON FAQs are CLICKED into EXISTENCE

Think the “Customer Ask” above search results are pre-written help docs?

Andrew Bell says they’re not written: they’re earned.

They didn’t come from a copywriter.

They came from shopper behavior—trained into existence by clicks inside Rufus.

❌ “They’re just generic questions.”
→ You're treating dynamic, conversion-trained data like filler.
→ And missing what actually drives behavior.

✅ Smart Move: Treat every surfaced question like a proven A/B-tested ad headline.
They made it there because shoppers clicked—and converted.

❌ “Rufus is just a chatbot.”
→ You’re ignoring the feedback loop.
→ You’re missing how shopper intent now reshapes the interface itself.

✅ Smart Move: Think of Rufus as Amazon’s newest CRO tool.
When a question → gets clicked → leads to adds-to-cart → drives sales and it gets promoted into the “Customers Ask” module.

❌ “FAQs don’t affect SEO.”
→ That’s old-school thinking.
→ Behavioral signals now shape ranking more than static keywords.

✅ Smart Move: Echo these winning questions in your:

• Bullet points

• A+ Content headers

• Brand Store sections

Amazon already tested the intent. You just need to align your content with what’s working.

These aren’t random questions. They’re click-trained artifacts of what converts.

If your content doesn’t answer them, the SERP will—using someone else’s listing.

📛  WANT to DIVE DEEPER into EVERYTHING ECOM?

Charles over at JustaSeller says he is the only guy writing a newsletter who still prints his shipping labels. He loves staying informed, but he doesn’t like an in-box full of junk.

So he carefully sorts all the newsletters he gets into two buckets: Signal (must-read now) and Noise (might have a nugget, but mostly clutter).

Here’s his list:

✌🏼 See you again Thursday …

The answer to today’s STUMP BEZOS is
81% of influencers use AI in some manner to create content